In the small, God-fearing town of Redemption Valley, a boy's dead body is found mutilated. Is it a ritualistic killing? The local bad boy, Joel Flood, is arrested and put in jail. A black-garbed, "devil-worshipping" metalhead, he must be guilty... or is he? Enter attorney and super hero Matt Murdock, brought in to save the troubled teen from what looks like a witch hunt by an outraged community desperate for justice... and the death penalty. This may be the most important case of Matt's career. A loss means justice denied and certain death for his client.